Snapback Problem 13 / Solution
![[Diagram]](../../diagrams/50/d15169eae2a05c8ec5c54a8dac98a776.png)
White dies
After
, a or b kills White.
Is
white's best defense? See below for options.
Things that don't work.
![[Diagram]](../../diagrams/31/721caeedc1d50d0947f60301af994fcf.png)
White lives
White lives and saves the marked stones with either a or b.
![[Diagram]](../../diagrams/17/6f4464a2bf322c704d0aa5dc12d03f90.png)
White lives
White lives with either a or b.
![[Diagram]](../../diagrams/40/f493cf642570299c8478386596ab1970.png)
White lives
White lives with either a or b.
In the original solution, white plays
@ a. However this loses, as shown above.
![[Diagram]](../../diagrams/9/0af604727be9d47a41431d1b546d1aa5.png)
Black to move, White lives?
I propose
, it secures an eye, and gives white the option to make another eye by playing a, b, or c. But it is black's turn, how does black kill now?
Obviously white @ a secures two eyes for white, so perhaps black playes there first.
![[Diagram]](../../diagrams/19/61e9862de358e1d116e5aedf3c8d3cb3.png)
White lives? Fig 1
looks promising (but actually fails)
![[Diagram]](../../diagrams/46/79bd5a164630dacb9947f92f5410a10f.png)
White lives? Fig 2
To continue from figure 1,
places the white group in atari . White @ c kills the black stone....
![[Diagram]](../../diagrams/21/da94d2c67834ccc47700442e121590ca.png)
White lives? Fig 3
But then we are back to a basic snap back position. Black kills the 5 white marked stones by playing @ a. So white dies even in this position.
![[Diagram]](../../diagrams/24/f4da54be616f0a29608c3b1af2b47539.png)
White lives? Fig 3
White's only other try is at
which is self-atari.
So white really is dead, sorry I did not see that. Perhaps the above options are obvious, but probably not to all.